Fetch the Bolt Cutters
Fiona Apple's percussive, freewheeling album earns near-perfect Metascores for untamed piano-and-bark songs with far more raw grit than softer radio fare.
Official site for Fetch the Bolt Cutters
Albums scored by Metacritic Metascore in 21 words.
Fiona Apple's percussive, freewheeling album earns near-perfect Metascores for untamed piano-and-bark songs with far more raw grit than softer radio fare.
Official site for Fetch the Bolt Cutters
Kendrick Lamar's jazz-rap landmark still tops decade-end lists for its political density, wrapped in a restless and unmistakably Los Angeles sound.
Official site for To Pimp a Butterfly
Kanye West's maximalist opus still tops critics' rap lists for craft, whatever listeners think of everything that followed in his career.
Official site for My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
Portishead's Bristol trip-hop debut still haunts critics as the cool, melancholy template that other artists keep sampling decades after its release.
Björk's Icelandic storm of strings and beats still sets the bar for avant-pop courage on critics' lists, decades after its release.
Beyoncé's visual album still defines modern pop ambition for critics who carefully weigh its artistic risk against its polished, stadium-sized scale.
Frank Ocean's summery debut still rewires R&B expectations with narrative cool that critics keep calling generational more than a decade later.
Official site for Channel Orange
Kendrick Lamar's Compton coming-of-age story plays like a film, and critics treat it as the gold standard of modern rap storytelling.
Official site for Good Kid, M.A.A.D City
This sparse, confessional indie record, the follow-up to Punisher, pairs sharp guests with aching late-night clarity that critics have widely praised.
Official site for Lost Weekend
This self-produced New York pop stays restless and bright, while its glitchy hooks cut through with surprising warmth, bite and ambition.
A sludge return a decade on, with Aaron Turner sharing vocals, earns near-universal acclaim for crushing spiritual weight and grim beauty.
Official site for An Undying Love For A Burning World
Staples's independent set leans on live bands and dry wit, so the menace feels human rather than cartoonish or emptily theatrical.
Radiohead's pay-what-you-want landmark still sounds modern, and critics keep returning to its restless art-rock warmth, digital-era nerves and lasting emotional pull.
The Ghanaian Australian rapper flexes theatrical bite and guest firepower on a third album that critics call inventive, bold and thrilling.
Official site for REDSTAR WU & THE WORLDWIDE SCOURGE
Frank Ocean's fragmented heartbreak still divides and obsesses critics, who measure its silences as seriously as its hooks on every listen.
Lana Del Rey's California novel-in-songs still earns lofty critic scores for lazy-river sadness, delivered with precision few modern pop albums sustain.
Official site for Norman Fucking Rockwell!
This Patrick Hyland-produced Mitski album stays surgically intimate, as melodies ache and quiet restraint becomes the loudest instrument across the record.
Official site for Nothing's About To Happen To Me
Cate Le Bon steers British post-punk talk-singing into cooler shapes, while the deadpan lines still sting like sharp morning news headlines.
Rodrigo's third album keeps its diary-pop catharsis sharp and even lands a Cure cameo without polishing away that raw teenage edge.
Official site for you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love
This September release from the Scottish duo keeps bleak humor and intimate narration that critics still find gripping, honest and raw.
Official site for Half-Told Tales
Winehouse's retro-soul heartbreak still devastates listeners with horns and honesty that have long outlived the tabloid noise that once surrounded her.
Official site for Back to Black
This list ranks 21 albums by their Metacritic Metascore, the weighted average of professional reviews that Metacritic publishes on a 0–100 scale, so the score you see is the Metascore itself. The selection mixes modern landmarks such as Fetch the Bolt Cutters and To Pimp a Butterfly with 1990s and 2000s classics and some of the best-reviewed records of 2026. Fetch the Bolt Cutters currently leads with 98. Metascores rarely move once an album has been out for a few weeks, so changes here usually mean a new release has entered. Every verdict is an original 21-word summary of what the record sounds like and why critics rate it. Last checked 2 November 2026.
Fetch the Bolt Cutters currently has the highest score, 98 out of 100, followed by To Pimp a Butterfly (96) and My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy (94). Scores were last checked on 2 November 2026.
Each score is the Metacritic Metascore itself (0–100). Every verdict is an original summary of exactly 21 words.
We re-check every score each Monday. If a source cannot be reached or a figure cannot be confirmed, we keep the previous score rather than guess, and every change is logged on our What changed this week page.
What changed this week · All head-to-head comparisons · All guides