Fairy pools, cliff drives and moody weather define Scottish island romance for hikers who accept midges and book around peak crowds.
Islands by region
Our Top 21 islands regrouped by region, so you can compare options within reach of where you are flying from. Scores map Tripadvisor traveler ratings to a 1–100 scale.
Europe & UK
6 picks; highest score here: Isle of Skye (92).
Caldera sunsets, whitewashed cliffs and volcanic beaches still overwhelm despite cruise crowds, and early mornings and shoulder-season timing reward visitors most.
Emerald coves, nuragic ruins and mountains reward weeks beyond the beach, offering wilder Mediterranean space without the Amalfi Coast's steep prices.
Volcanoes, ruins, markets and coastal drives pack Mediterranean depth into one island for travelers wanting food, history and sea air together.
Lavender hills, harbor nightlife and swims around the Pakleni islands keep Dalmatian summers busy for yacht day-trippers and longer-stay visitors alike.
Tramuntana trails, cove swims and Palma's old town reward itineraries beyond the resorts, trading megayacht clichés for mountain and village days.
Asia
6 picks; highest score here: Palawan (92).
Limestone lagoons, island hopping and underground rivers still stun despite crowds, rewarding early boats and responsible tour operators over sprawling mega-resorts.
Temples, rice terraces and surf coasts keep drawing wellness travelers, though traffic pushes visitors toward quieter villages in the island's east.
Volcanic trails, black-sand coasts and Hallasan hikes give Korea an island reset that feels wilder than any typical weekend in Seoul.
Reef swims, island-chain hops and Ryukyu culture give Japan a tropical change of pace from the temple-and-train routines of the mainland.
Duty-free coves, mangrove trips and cable-car views make Malaysian island weekends easy for regional flyers who prefer calm coves to malls.
Beach variety and island day trips still deliver, though Patong's chaos pushes better stays toward quieter bays on the west coast.
Africa & Indian Ocean
4 picks; highest score here: Réunion (90).
Active volcanoes, dramatic cirques and Creole trails bring French Indian Ocean drama to hikers who want alpine-feeling days beside tropical coasts.
Spice farms, Stone Town alleys and Indian Ocean beaches blend Swahili history with resort ease for travelers hopping East African islands.
Lagoon resorts, Creole kitchens and hikes pack Indian Ocean variety into one island reached by flights from Africa, Asia and Europe.
Trade-wind beaches, Creole music and island-hopping flights offer European weekenders an Atlantic African escape without the visa friction of the mainland.
Latin America
3 picks; highest score here: Galápagos (96).
Strict permits and rare Darwinian wildlife encounters keep this Pacific archipelago a once-in-a-lifetime nature trip best taken only with responsible operators.
Permit-limited reefs and dramatic cliffs protect this Brazilian Atlantic wonder, rewarding advance bookings with quiet snorkeling days mainland beaches cannot match.
Car-free sand streets, bioluminescent nights and whale-shark season sell a slower Caribbean Mexico to travelers escaping the megahotel density of Cancun.
Oceania & North America
2 picks; highest score here: Tasmania (92).
Wilderness trails, cool-climate wine and Hobart's food scene reward travelers who want an Australia wilder and cooler than mainland beach defaults.
The Road to Hana, volcano sunrises and beach variety define bucket-list Hawaii for travelers who pace their drives and respect closures.
How these scores work
Every line is exactly 21 words, an original paraphrase of public consensus. Scores (1–100) are mapped from named public aggregates, last checked 2026-11-02:
- Islands: Tripadvisor traveler rating ×20
Links go to each subject’s official site. Disclaimer.